
Design dollars that are well-spent can pay large dividends. While design accounts for 5% of total cost, it determines over 70% of finished product cost. Investing in smart design can lead to substantial savings and better performance.
This summary discussion provides an overview of the essential engineering concepts needed to design successful plastic parts. The focus is on clear explanations and practical advice for those who use plastics in manufacturing.
Why Design Matters
Design is the foundation of any successful product, especially when working with plastics. It has an outsized impact on the final product’s price, quality, and performance.
Avoid costly mistakes by taking time to balance material choice based on performance properties with requirements for easy manufacturing and assembly.
In today’s competitive market, products need to be developed faster, making it even more important to get the design and material choice right the first time. Teams that bring together experts from different disciplines (like design, engineering, and manufacturing) can spot problems early and build in quality from the start.
Design engineers want to do the job right the first time, but over-engineering can result in unacceptable delays and cost overruns. Similarly, choosing a material because it’s well known or was used in a similar project won’t guarantee your success.
That’s why it’s worth partnering with an experienced plastics manufacturer. Look for someone who can help you with material selection, design for manufacturing (DFM) expertise, and even assemble and ship your products.
Main Concepts for Plastic Part Design
Engineers need to master the following fundamental mechanical concepts.
- Strength and rigidity
- Creep
- Fatigue
- Impact resistance
- Thermal considerations
- Chemical resistance
- Fastening and assembly
Apply them to your designs and partner with Profile Plastics to ensure performance and support market success.
Strength and Rigidity
Understanding strength and rigidity is crucial for making plastic parts that work well and last. These two properties are often confused, but they are not the same. Strength is about how much force a part can manage before breaking, while rigidity describes how much it resists bending or flexing.
Critical Questions
- What kind of loads will the part face (pull, bend, heat)?
- What level of force will be applied?
- How is it held in place?
- What are the temperature conditions (in use or shipping, how long)?
- What counts as a failure (breaking, bending too much)?
Plastics are not as strong as metals, but with clever design, changing the shape or thickness, plastic parts can carry similar loads. Plastics behave differently from metals because they are “viscoelastic,” meaning their properties change with time, temperature, and how fast a load is applied. For a successful design, you need to know what types of loads it will face, how much force will be applied, how the part is held in place, and what the temperature conditions will be.
Stress/strain curves, which show how a material stretches or bends under a load, are important tools. The modulus of elasticity (Young’s modulus) measures stiffness, used for making static short-term loading calculations. When strain exceeds the proportional limit, deflection is more likely to be permanent after the load is removed.
Design Tips
Designers can make plastic parts as rigid as metal ones by making them thicker or adding ribs for support. For example, doubling the thickness of a plastic part can offset a much lower modulus compared to metal. Well-designed plastic parts can be as rigid as steel or aluminum, while being lighter, corrosion-resistant, and offering more styling options.
Creep
Creep, or long-term deformation, is an important consideration for plastic parts that need to hold a load over a prolonged period. It’s also called cold flow and happens when a plastic part slowly deforms under a constant load, especially at higher temperatures.
Critical Questions
- What is the stress on the part?
- How long will the stress be applied?
- What temperature will it experience under load?
When a plastic part is subjected to a steady force, it will deform quickly at first and then continue to deform more slowly over time. The most visible effect happens in the first six weeks, but it can continue for years. Glass fiber-reinforced plastics resist creep much better than regular plastics.
Testing for creep is usually done by loading a bar and measuring how it bends over time. Engineers use the “apparent modulus” (stiffness over time) to predict the amount of bending. Testing can be done in either tensile or more common flexural mode.
For example, when designing a plastic bookshelf, you can use these calculations to choose the right thickness, so the shelves won’t sag. This shows how engineering principles can be applied to real-world situations to prevent long-term failures.
Design Tips
To design against creep, you need to know the expected load, how long it will last, and the temperature conditions.
Fatigue
Fatigue is a common cause of failure in plastic parts that are loaded and unloaded many times. Even if a part can handle a single load, repeated cycles can eventually cause it to fail.
Critical Questions
- How many cycles will the part endure?
- What level of strain does the load add?
- What is the frequency of the load?
- Does the temperature rise due to the frequency?
Testing for fatigue involves applying a load repeatedly to a test piece and counting the number of cycles it takes to break. Both the number of cycles and the size of the load matter. Higher frequency loading can heat up the plastic, making it fail sooner. Flaws in the part, like voids or weld lines, can make fatigue worse.
Fatigue testing is useful for comparing materials, but real-world testing is often needed for final designs.
Design Tips
To reduce fatigue problems, designers can add a safety factor to a part. Add ribs or stiffeners to reduce stress, or you can spread out the load. Lower the frequency of repeated loads, if possible. To deal with temperature, make walls thinner to help transfer heat, or improve air flow to cool the part. Using these strategies helps prevent unexpected failures in parts that experience repeated stress.
Impact Resistance
Impact resistance measures how well a plastic part can handle sudden blows or drops. This property is hard to predict for real-world behavior, but it’s important for many applications.
The design, environment, and processing of a part can influence its impact strength more than the material itself. If you know the application’s requirements, you can engineer the part for the proper material.
There are two main tests. Izod tests measure how much energy a notched bar can absorb before breaking. This is useful for testing lot to lot quality consistency. Falling Weight tests drop a weight onto the part. These are becoming standard because they offer more real-world insight. Results can vary based on the thickness and shape of the sample, so it’s important to evaluate real parts.
Design Tips
To design for impact, find which areas of the part are most likely to get hit, and remove sharp corners or notches that can concentrate stress. Consider increasing wall thickness or adding ribs to increase strength.
Don’t just pick the material with the highest test value. Instead, assess the actual part in real-world conditions to make sure it performs as needed.
Thermal Considerations
Plastics react to heat differently than metals, and high temperatures can make them softer, weaker, or cause them to deform.
Critical Questions:
- What is the highest temperature for the application?
- How long will the part be exposed to that temperature?
- What is the shipping temperature?
- How much/what kind of stress will the part experience?
- How critical are dimension changes due to temperature?
End-use temperature is important, but shipping temperatures can be more concerning. Temperatures in transit may reach 230-240°F, which can cause warping. However, extreme low temperatures can cause cracking failures.
A realistic test of thermal stress is to find the warp temperature. This is simply the temperature at which a part becomes dimensionally unstable or distorted. The ball pressure test is also common today. It measures dimensional stability under stress at elevated temperatures.
It’s important to know the maximum temperature your part will face during use and shipping, and to choose a plastic that can manage those conditions. Thermally cycling a part through the range of expected temperatures helps to see performance.
Design Tips
Some plastics handle heat better than others. Always check the manufacturer’s data and, if possible, test your part under real conditions to avoid surprises. When your part is assembled from two different materials, accommodate any relative movement due to heat or cold through slots, oversize holes with energy-absorbing grommets, or flexible adhesives.
Chemical Resistance
Chemical resistance is the ability of plastic material to withstand exposure to chemicals without degrading. Some plastics resist chemicals well, while others do not.
Critical Questions:
- To what chemicals will the part be exposed?
- What is the concentration?
- What is the length of exposure?
- What will be the highest temperature of exposure?
Some chemicals attack plastics quickly, while less aggressive chemical solutions may take weeks or months to cause a problem. A given material may also experience partial loss of strength in response to chemical exposure.
Chemical effects on plastic polymers can include:
- Envronmental stress cracking
- Embrittlement (mechanical breakdown of the plastic)
- Absorption (permeate the plastic, causing it to grow soft)i
- Solvation
- Staining
Before choosing a material, find out what chemicals the part will contact, such as cleaners or fuels. Test the plastic with the actual chemical, if possible, since even small differences in formulation can affect performance.
Design Tips
Consider design alternatives for applications exposed to aggressive environmental factors like chemicals. Redesign the part, increase wall thickness, or integrate a protective film barrier. The last alternative is to use a different material, or replace the chemical agent (alternative lubricants, adhesives, or cleaners).
Fastening and Assembly
How you join plastic parts together affects their strength and durability. Innovative fastening methods like snap-fits can save time and money, allowing for easy assembly and disassembly. However, they must be designed carefully to avoid stress concentration.
Critical Questions:
- Can parts be permanently bonded, or will they need to be reassembled?
- For what fastening system is your manufacturing most experienced?
- Does one method save time on the assembly line rather than another?
A large part of the total product cost is labor on the assembly line and components for assembly (screws, inserts, adhesives, radio-frequency welding). Innovation and creativity in the assembly process can save cost and improve quality.
Design considerations include: the strength needed, tooling cost, labor cost, aesthetic requirements, ease of assembly, amount of time, and regulatory constraints.
Design Tips
Work with your manufacturing team early to choose the best fastening method for your design. This helps prevent problems during assembly and ensures the final product meets performance goals.
Key Takeaways for Designers and Engineers
Designing with plastics requires a clear understanding of the stress-inducing factors that your parts will face. Close cooperation with your manufacturing team avoids surprises and costly changes later. Here are the four key points to remember:
- Start with clear requirements: Know the loads, temperatures, chemicals, and impacts.
- Choose materials based on performance, not just reputation or past use.
- Use design features like ribs or thicker walls to make plastics perform as well as metals.
- Test your designs under real-world conditions whenever possible.
Conclusion
There are a variety of ways to achieve a well-designed part. By mastering these basic engineering concepts, you can design plastic parts that are strong, reliable, and cost-effective. Focus on the real needs of your product, use the right tests and calculations, and collaborate with your team to deliver successful products every time.
Not all materials or even all tests are right for a specific application.
It’s important to partner with a plastics manufacturer with expertise and experience that meets your needs. Profile Plastics can help you select the best thermoforming process and specific material to create better parts.
The ideas shared here are adapted from “Design Success Through Solution Engineering,” published in the 1990s by J. H. Hawley of Eastman Performance Plastics, a divisionof Eastman Chemical Company.
Let’s talk about how to make your part right.Our guiding principle for doing business is simple but powerful: We’ll make it right. Schedule a Call with one of our experts, or use our Contact Form to start a conversation. |
